Skip to main content
Back to articles
Public Transport Economics, Finance & Fares

Fare evasion on local public transport:almost one in eight passengers does not pay for their bus ticket

For the first time, the analysis provides an accurate map of fare evasion in Local Public Transport (LPT). It presents the results of a large auditing and data-intelligence campaign that combines the analysis of the sector's financial statements with the figures from on-board ticket inspections carried out by HOLACHECK. Using statistical weighting models, this real-world evidence has been extended and projected nationwide, revealing a structural evasion rate of 15.6% (about 1 passenger in 8). The phenomenon creates an estimated financial gap of around €718 million a year in lost revenue for the sector: a huge sum that recurs every twelve months.

Share

Follow us

The phenomenon of fare evasion in Local Public Transport (LPT) represents one of the main structural challenges to the economic and financial sustainability of the transport sector in Italy. Despite its significance, the phenomenon has historically been the subject of fragmented analyses, often based on local perceptions or ad hoc surveys rather than on established statistical methodologies.

This analysis presents the results of an extensive auditing and data-intelligence campaign that combines an analysis of the sector’s annual financial statements with numerical evidence derived from on-the-ground audit activities carried out by Holacheck.

Methodology and Sample Representativeness

A sample of public transport operators was selected, operating in a variety of contexts (high-density urban areas, suburban networks, metropolitan services, tramways and funicular railways) across the whole of the country. The data were subsequently extrapolated to a national scale using statistical weighting models.

Table 1: Indicators of the representativeness of the statistical sample (year 2025)

Sector macro-indicatorAggregate sample valueEstimated total for ItalySample share
Service volume (vehicle-km)346.8 million1.8 billion19.27%
Traffic revenue (fare revenue in €)€ 299.5 million€ 1.9 billion15.76%
Economic value (value of production in €)€ 1,260 million€ 8 billion15.87%

The even distribution of the firms in the sample means that the behaviours and evasion rates observed can be regarded as reliable predictive clusters for statistical purposes when projecting results onto a national scale.

Assessment of the Economic Loss

The data, compiled by cross-referencing the number of passengers checked on board with the results of the actual inspections, reveal a double-digit structural fare evasion rate (15.6 per cent), which is consistent both within the sample and at the national level.

The consequences of this unlawful behaviour result in direct economic loss for companies (lost ticket revenue) and a loss of tax revenue for the public purse (10% VAT on the value of the lost ticket revenue).

Performance / impact indicatorMeasured value (sample)National estimate
Fines issued830 thousand4.4 million
Estimated annual lost fare revenue€ 46.6 million€ 296 million
VAT evaded per year (10%)€ 4.3 million€ 27 million

THE DATA SHOW THAT IN ITALY, APPROXIMATELY ONE IN EIGHT PASSENGERS TRAVELS WITHOUT A VALID TICKET, COSTING THE TRANSPORT SYSTEM APPROXIMATELY 296 MILLION EUROS A YEAR IN DIRECT FARE REVENUE ALONE.

Collection Dynamics and Structural Insolvency

The effectiveness of the penalty system does not end when the infringement is notified (the fine is issued), but is measured by the rate at which the sums due are actually collected. Around 40% is collected; the remaining 60% of the fines issued fall into a state of permanent non-payment, generating a volume of uncollected debt that accumulates and is regenerated cyclically each year, estimated at around €395 million nationwide.

Conclusion

The economic findings presented here demonstrate unequivocally that fare evasion in public transport can no longer be dismissed as a mere micro-social phenomenon or a ‘collateral cost’ of normal operations. From a macroeconomic perspective, this phenomenon generates an estimated total financial shortfall of around 718 million euros per year in lost revenue for the sector. This is a huge figure that recurs cyclically every twelve months and stems from the combination of three critical factors:

  • €296 million in lost direct revenue from the sale of travel tickets;
  • €395 million in fines that remain unpaid and uncollected;
  • €27 million in evaded VAT on unsold tickets, representing a direct loss to the Treasury

Combating fare evasion is therefore not a punitive measure, but the fundamental prerequisite for setting in motion a virtuous cycle: greater compliance on board means more resources, better services and fairer public transport for everyone.

Follow us

Newsletter

Stay Updated

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive the latest reports.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.