Skip to main content

Cooperativa Trasporti Riolo Terme

Analysis of the sustainability of the coach hire service and company valuation

Two assignments for Cooperativa Trasporti Riolo Terme, a public transport and coach hire operator in the Faenza area: an economic analysis of the coach hire service and the valuation of a local operator to support an extraordinary transaction.

Client
Cooperativa Trasporti Riolo Terme
Service
Operational Excellence & Process Optimization, M&A Advisory
Projects
Analysis of the coach hire service, company valuation
Years
2023-2025

2023Profitability analysis

Analysis of the economic sustainability of the coach hire with driver service

Analysis of the current and future profitability of coach hire with driver, with proposed measures on fares, management control and sales organisation.

The coach hire with driver market

The sector suffered a sharp decline during the pandemic and in 2023 had not yet returned to previous levels. It is a market in which operators often combine several services and in which demand is highly seasonal.

-75%

average fall in coach hire turnover during the pandemic

60%+

of the sector's turnover generated by companies that also provide other transport services

34%

of the sector's activity aimed at students, between school trips and school transport

Sources: pre- and post-pandemic sector data, Basco&T analysis.

The context

The Cooperativa operates a local public transport service contract and, with the same staff and partly with the same vehicles, a coach hire with driver service for private customers, travel agencies, schools and associations.

As across the whole sector, after the pandemic coach hire was recovering its volumes, against a background of rising fuel and maintenance costs. The Cooperativa wanted to define the conditions for consolidating and developing this business.

What we did

  1. Separating the accounts

    Allocation of the income statement and balance sheet between public transport and coach hire, with direct and indirect drivers and an estimate of the time staff devote to each activity.

  2. Service analysis

    Types of service offered, customer mix, fare system, seasonality of demand and fleet utilisation compared with potential capacity.

  3. Coach hire income statement

    Comparison between the pre-pandemic period and the current year, and margin analysis by type of service and type of vehicle.

    • Half-day, full-day and multi-day services
    • Cars, minibuses and touring coaches
    • Operating margin and weight of depreciation
  4. Market analysis

    Size of the commercial transport services market, effects of the pandemic and trends in the main segments, with scenarios for how demand may evolve.

  5. Proposed measures

    Actions to strengthen the sustainability of the service and develop it.

The proposals

Fares

Aligning prices with the cost structure.

Fare review
Fares differentiated by type of service, season and level of demand, following revenue management principles.
Business development
Marketing activities to reach new customer segments.

Management control

Measuring profitability on an ongoing basis.

Reporting
Periodic reports on volumes, revenues and costs by type of service and vehicle.

Synergies with other operators

Reducing seasonality and broadening the market.

Sales network
A sales plan and a booking centre shared with other local operators.
Integrated management
Centralised service scheduling to improve vehicle utilisation.

Market segments

The growing areas of demand.

Tourism
Cruise, airport, religious and school tourism.
Events
Business travel, conferences and incentive travel.

What we delivered

  • Separation of accounts between public transport and coach hire
  • Analysis of the service, customers and seasonality
  • Coach hire income statement by type of service and vehicle
  • Analysis of the commercial services market and demand scenarios
  • Proposals on fares, management control and commercial synergies

2025Company valuation

Valuation of a local transport operator

Estimate of the value of a local public transport and coach hire operator, to support an extraordinary transaction.

Valuation methods applied

The value was estimated using four different methods, to obtain a solid reference range for the negotiation.

  1. ScopeServices, staff and fleet subject to valuation
  2. Asset-basedAdjusted net assets
  3. Income-basedNormalised and discounted profitability
  4. MultiplesEBITDA multiples of comparable companies
  5. FinancialDiscounted cash flows (DCF)

For each method, the enterprise value was adjusted for net financial position and employee severance pay (TFR).

Source: Basco&T valuation.

The context

The Cooperativa was considering an extraordinary transaction involving a local operator active in public transport and coach hire with driver.

Before negotiations, it needed an independent estimate of the company's value and the identification of issues to be examined in due diligence.

What we did

  1. Defining the scope

    Shareholder structure, services provided, staff and fleet involved in the transaction.

  2. Analysis of historical data

    Income statement and balance sheet for recent financial years, with normalisation of extraordinary items.

  3. Applying the valuation methods

    Asset-based, income-based, EBITDA multiples and discounted cash flow methods, with the results summarised in a value range.

  4. Estimating the service margin

    Estimated income statement of the public transport service included in the scope.

  5. Issues for due diligence

    Points to be examined during due diligence, to protect the client in the negotiation.

What we delivered

  • Analysis of the scope of the transaction
  • Valuation using four methods and value range
  • Estimate of the public transport service margin
  • List of points to be examined in due diligence

More Operational Excellence & Process Optimization projects

View all projects
Start Romagna

Start Romagna

Assessment of accounts receivable and payable procedures

Mapping of administrative processes, analysis of the causes of delays in recording invoices, and new procedures in SAP.

Read the project
ATC Esercizio, La Spezia

ATC Esercizio, La Spezia

Workload mapping and new organisational structure

Analysis of the workloads and critical processes of four company departments and two options for a new organisation chart.

Read the project

Holacheck

Holacheck

Process review and business intelligence for ticket inspection services

Objective criteria for planning inspections, integration of client data, management dashboard and automated database.

Read the project

Want to check the profitability of your business lines?

Tell us what you need: we reply within one working day.