[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"mm-article:recidivi-nel-trasporto-pubblico-locale:en:live":3},{"slug":4,"date":5,"theme":6,"featured":7,"title":8,"abstract":9,"cover":10,"coverAlt":11,"infographic":12,"infographicAlt":13,"infographicLarge":14,"infographicCount":15,"blocks":16,"metaDescription":9,"infographicFull":92,"infographics":93,"seo":96,"language":97,"unpublished":7,"related":98},"recidivi-nel-trasporto-pubblico-locale","2026-08-05","economia-finanza-tariffe",false,"Repeat offenders in local public transport: when fines accumulate but remain uncollected","The analysis of repeat offenders highlights one of the main critical issues in combating fare evasion: issuing a fine alone guarantees neither payment nor an effective deterrent effect. The sample examined is based on data collected by Holacheck as part of ticket inspection activities. Despite being correctly identified, these individuals continue to accumulate citations without changing their behavior. The data demonstrates that the effectiveness of inspections depends primarily on the ability of transit companies to turn issued fines into actual collected receivables.","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F94b4539a-43df-4774-8ae7-65711dcc5363?width=800&format=webp","Mobility Metrics cover on repeat fare evaders: ID cards with made-up names and caricatures, such as \"Struzzo Corridore\" with 268 fines, nearly all unpaid","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fb7745df5-f853-4ac7-9dd9-d16e39160033?width=500&format=webp","Infographic on the six worst repeat offenders, under made-up names: between 268 and 121 fines each with virtually none paid, showing that fines alone do not deter","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fb7745df5-f853-4ac7-9dd9-d16e39160033?width=1000&format=webp",1,[17,20,22,24,26,58,62,64,66,68,70,72,74,82,84,86,88,90],{"type":18,"html":19},"paragraph","\u003Cp>In local public transport, there is a category of fare evaders who do not simply travel without a ticket on an occasional basis. These are \u003Cstrong>repeat offenders\u003C\u002Fstrong>—passengers who continue using the service without a valid ticket, accumulating fines over the years without paying them.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":18,"html":21},"\u003Cp>The sample analyzed includes a total of 1,024 violations. On average, each individual received approximately \u003Cstrong>170 fines\u003C\u002Fstrong>, with the number of violations ranging from 121 to 268 per person.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":18,"html":23},"\u003Cp>The most significant finding concerns payments. Five out of six individuals did not pay a single fine they received. The only individual who made any payments settled just 2 out of 126 fines, leaving 124 unpaid.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":18,"html":25},"\u003Cp>Overall, the payment rate across the sample is therefore only 0.20%. \u003Cstrong>0,20%\u003C\u002Fstrong>.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":27,"head":28,"rows":33,"numeric":55,"rowHeads":56,"title":57,"caption":57},"table",[29,30,31,32],"Repeat offenders","Fines received","Fines paid","Fines unpaid",[34,38,41,44,47,52],[35,36,37,36],"Repeat offender 1","268","0",[39,40,37,40],"Repeat offender 2","183",[42,43,37,43],"Repeat offender 3","167",[45,46,37,46],"Repeat offender 4","159",[48,49,50,51],"Repeat offender 5","126","2","124",[53,54,37,54],"Repeat offender 6","121",[7,56,56,56],true,null,{"type":59,"level":60,"text":61},"heading",2,"The Limits of Uncollected Fines",{"type":18,"html":63},"\u003Cp>These figures demonstrate that, in the absence of an effective debt recovery process, repeated ticket inspections risk generating nothing more than an ever-growing stock of receivables that are unlikely to be collected.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":18,"html":65},"\u003Cp>A fine retains its deterrent effect only when offenders perceive a real likelihood that they will eventually have to pay it. Conversely, when dozens or even hundreds of fines can accumulate without any tangible financial consequences, the deterrent mechanism gradually loses its effectiveness.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":18,"html":67},"\u003Cp>For repeat offenders, a fine risks becoming not a real cost but merely an administrative record. For the transport operator, however, every new penalty entails inspection activities, administrative processing, notification, and debt recovery efforts, without necessarily generating any corresponding financial return.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":18,"html":69},"\u003Cp>Ticket inspection therefore creates a receivable, but it is the collection of that receivable that ultimately transforms it into an economic resource for the public transport system.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":59,"level":60,"text":71},"From Identification to Collection",{"type":18,"html":73},"\u003Cp>The evidence shows that the issue cannot be addressed simply by increasing the number of ticket inspections. Instead, it is essential to strengthen the entire enforcement chain that follows the issuance of a fine:\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":75,"ordered":7,"icon":57,"items":76},"list",[77,78,79,80,81],"timely identification of repeat offenders;","continuous monitoring of accumulated outstanding debts;","prompt notification and follow-up reminders within the required timeframes;","faster and more structured debt recovery procedures;","activation of enforcement measures for the most significant outstanding cases.",{"type":18,"html":83},"\u003Cp>The availability of accurate personal identification data is a fundamental prerequisite. However, unless this information is effectively used to support a systematic debt recovery process, the benefits of identifying offenders remain largely unrealized.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":59,"level":60,"text":85},"Conclusion",{"type":18,"html":87},"\u003Cp>The case of repeat offenders clearly demonstrates that the fight against fare evasion does not end with the issuance of a fine. A system capable of issuing thousands of penalties but unable to collect them risks penalizing primarily those who comply with the rules, while leaving the behaviour of the most persistent fare evaders largely unchanged.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":18,"html":89},"\u003Cp>The objective should not simply be to issue more fines, but to ensure that penalties have concrete, proportionate, and predictable consequences.\u003C\u002Fp>\n",{"type":18,"html":91},"\u003Cp>\u003Cstrong>An uncollected fine represents more than just lost revenue—it undermines the credibility of the entire enforcement system\u003C\u002Fstrong>. Strengthening the collection process therefore means not only recovering financial resources, but also protecting law-abiding passengers and restoring the deterrent effect of fare enforcement.\u003C\u002Fp>\n","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fb7745df5-f853-4ac7-9dd9-d16e39160033",[94],{"thumb":95,"large":14,"full":92,"alt":13},"\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fb7745df5-f853-4ac7-9dd9-d16e39160033?width=200&format=webp",{"title":57,"description":57,"image":57,"noindex":7},"en",[99,110,120],{"slug":100,"date":101,"theme":6,"featured":7,"title":102,"abstract":103,"cover":104,"coverAlt":105,"infographic":106,"infographicAlt":107,"infographicLarge":108,"infographicCount":109},"caro-diesel-e-extragettito-iva-tpl","2026-10-26","Diesel price surges and additional VAT revenues for the state: the proposal for a fuel price stabilization fund for public transport","Diesel prices, now driven by geopolitical factors rather than crude oil prices, are generating substantial additional VAT revenues for the state, making temporary subsidies to public transport operators inadequate and unsustainable. The sector is not facing a temporary shock, but a “new normal” that calls for structural measures based on the redistribution of additional VAT revenues.","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F3bd7981b-7855-40ec-afc4-4e091085cf40?width=800&format=webp","Mobility Metrics cover on diesel prices: fuel can showing an average self-service price of €2.281\u002Fl, of which €0.984\u002Fl is VAT and excise, and a crack spread above $100 a barrel","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F5b32084f-2809-48dd-909e-3a0a65f08378?width=500&format=webp","Infographic on diesel prices: €2.281\u002Fl (€0.984 VAT and excise), crack spread up from $15–25 to over $100 a barrel, and the industrial price rising faster than Brent in 2026","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F5b32084f-2809-48dd-909e-3a0a65f08378?width=1000&format=webp",3,{"slug":111,"date":112,"theme":6,"featured":7,"title":113,"abstract":114,"cover":115,"coverAlt":116,"infographic":117,"infographicAlt":118,"infographicLarge":119,"infographicCount":15},"evasione-tariffaria-tpl-lombardia","2026-10-13","Fare evasion in local public transport in Lombardy: a loss of €137 million a year","The analysis, based on data collected by Holacheck, reveals the economic impact of fare evasion in Lombardy: over 14% of passengers do not pay for a ticket, generating an estimated economic loss of €137.5 million per year in lost revenue and uncollected fines. The phenomenon is concentrated mainly among young people: over 53% of fined passengers are under 26. Timely collection proves decisive: only 45.4% of fines are collected, while more than half remain unpaid, highlighting weaknesses in the system for recovering the sums owed.","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F1f48f731-4248-44fd-b58c-a5689fcc0ea5?width=800&format=webp","Mobility Metrics cover on fare evasion in Lombardy: actual rate of 14.2% and an estimated €137.5 million annual shortfall, shown with a Milan tram and the Duomo","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fd4912201-5dc0-4945-8189-25245c5f80dc?width=500&format=webp","Infographic on fare evasion in Lombardy: 14.2% rate and a €137.5 million annual loss; 53% of those fined are under 26 and only 45% of fines are collected","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002Fd4912201-5dc0-4945-8189-25245c5f80dc?width=1000&format=webp",{"slug":121,"date":122,"theme":6,"featured":7,"title":123,"abstract":124,"cover":125,"coverAlt":126,"infographic":127,"infographicAlt":128,"infographicLarge":129,"infographicCount":15},"scaglioni-sanzioni-trasporto","2026-07-22","The price of delay: time brackets as a lever to improve fine collection in local public transport","In local public transport, a tiered penalty structure proves to be an effective incentive for prompt payment. This analysis is based on a sample of public transport operators built from data collected by Holacheck during fare inspection activities in 2025. The results show that more than 70% of payments are made within the first five days, while voluntary payments after sixty days are virtually non-existent. A comparison across operators highlights that an early increase in the amount of the fine encourages recipients to pay sooner, reducing procrastination and unpaid fines. More than the amount of the fine itself, it is the design of the penalty tiers that determines the effectiveness of the collection system.","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F141684f9-a9be-4078-b331-743b3f1a9eaf?width=800&format=webp","Mobility Metrics cover on fine payment brackets: average cost €60 within 5 days, €79 up to 60 days and €211 thereafter; 71% of payments are made within 5 days","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F2f110278-7c23-4442-9dd1-68b30b596c8c?width=500&format=webp","Infographic comparing two fine bracket schemes: at €60\u002F€79\u002F€211, 71% pay within 5 days; with a flat €70 up to 60 days, only 41% do","\u002Fapi\u002Fassets\u002F2f110278-7c23-4442-9dd1-68b30b596c8c?width=1000&format=webp"]