Skip to main content
All insights

National Transport Fund:rethinking an allocation mechanism that does not reflect local needs

The National Transport Fund (FNT) is a funding mechanism established in 2011 by the Italian government as part of the fiscal federalism process. It aims to support local public transport by road and rail and is a strategic resource for the sector. Funding and…

Light-blue city bus speeding along an urban street, overlaid with the article title on the National Transport Fund and regional disparities

How to overcome regional disparities

National Transport Fund allocation criteria

The National Transport Fund (FNT) is a funding mechanism established in 2011 by the Italian government as part of the fiscal federalism process. It aims to support local public transport by road and rail and is a strategic resource for the sector.

National Transport Fund (FNT) funding and allocation in 2023

In 2023, the FNT reached total funding of €5.054 billion, allocated through a mixed system that combines historical funding levels with performance-based criteria linked to standard costs.

Breakdown of the 2023 National Transport Fund
€5.054 billionTotal FNT allocation
Breakdown of the 2023 National Transport Fund
Quota
Historical share96.4%
Performance-based and standard-cost share3.6%

The National Transport Fund is allocated through two main components:

Historical share (96.4%): calculated on the basis of historical allocations to the regions, it takes into account parameters such as the population served, the demand for public transport, and the size and complexity of the regional local public transport system.

Performance share (3.6%): this component is intended to reward regions that show improvement in the management of public transport. The allocation criteria include the efficiency of services, environmental sustainability and growth in ridership. However, given its weight in the total resources allocated, this performance share has a limited impact.

The current allocation system reflects an incomplete transition towards a merit-based model grounded in quality and efficiency. The predominance of the historical component favours the traditionally better-funded regions, while the introduction of standard costs, although an initial step, still has only a marginal impact on the overall balance of the allocation. Under this allocation criterion, Lombardy (17.4%), Lazio (11.7%) and Campania (11.1%) are the regions receiving the largest shares of the fund.

FNT allocation by region
FNT allocation by region
FNT (€ million)Share (%)
Lombardy876 € million17.33%
Lazio596 € million11.79%
Campania547 € million10.83%
Piedmont497 € million9.84%
Tuscany444 € million8.79%
Veneto410 € million8.11%
Apulia402 € million7.96%
Emilia-Romagna381 € million7.54%
Calabria212 € million4.19%
Liguria205 € million4.06%
Abruzzo138 € million2.74%
Marche112 € million2.21%
Umbria106 € million2.09%
Basilicata79 € million1.57%
Molise37 € million0.73%

Looking at the allocation of the performance share alone, regions such as Campania, Piedmont, Lombardy and Calabria appear to be penalised, with a performance share lower than the weight of their historical share.

Difference between historical share and performance-based share
Difference between historical share and performance-based share
RegioneValore
Abruzzo0.8%
Basilicata0.1%
Calabria-1%
Campania-6.9% · Historical share 11.1% · performance-based share 4.2%
Emilia-Romagna4.4% · Historical share 7.4% · performance-based share 11.8%
Lazio2.9% · Historical share 11.7% · performance-based share 14.6%
Ligurian.d.
Lombardia-0.1%
Marche0.6%
Molise0.6%
Piemonte-0.9%
Puglia-1.2%
Toscana-0.5%
Umbria0.9%
Veneto1%

Campania, with a historical share of 11.1%, sees its performance share reduced to 4.2%, equivalent to approximately €7.5 million, revealing a significant shortfall (-6.9%). Regions such as Lazio and Emilia–Romagna show the opposite trend. Emilia-Romagna, for example, goes from a historical share of 7.4% to a performance share of 11.8% (approximately €21 million), a positive balance of +4.4%.

Limits and disparities in the allocation system

An analysis of the distribution of the National Transport Fund (FNT) per inhabitant across the regions reveals significant disparities in per capita funding.

FNT allocation per capita by region
€ per inhabitant, 2023 data
FNT allocation per capita by region
Valore
Basilicata147.2 €
Liguria135.9 €
Molise127.5 €
Umbria122.2 €
Tuscany121.7 €
Calabria116.7 €
Piedmont116.5 €
Abruzzo108.2 €
Apulia104.5 €
Lazio104.1 €
Campania97.8 €
Lombardy87.6 €
Veneto86.5 €
Marche74.7 €

Basilicata (€147.2), Liguria (€135.9) and Molise (€127.5) are the regions with the highest per capita funding. This is mainly due to their small population relative to the total amount of funding received, resulting in per capita values above the average.

Conversely, in more densely populated regions such as Lombardy and Campania, the impact of the resources received is diluted by the higher demand for public transport. This can lead to an underestimation of these areas' needs in terms of adequate funding.

These figures reflect a structural trend in which less populated regions receive an amount of funding that is not necessarily proportional to population density or transport demand.

The Constitutional Court also highlights the shortcomings of a model in need of updating

In judgment no. 133 of 9 May–18 July 2023, the Constitutional Court highlighted the need to complete the legislative process initiated by Law no. 42/2009, aimed at the transition to a funding system based on standard costs and service levels, in order to ensure a fair distribution of resources and services of consistent quality throughout the country.

Future outlook

The National Transport Fund is a fundamental element in supporting local public transport, yet its current allocation shows shortcomings linked to the way resources are assigned. The stability provided by the historical allocation and the incentives linked to the performance share are central aspects, but there is a clear need to adapt the system to the new challenges and demands of the regions.

To improve the effectiveness and fairness of the Fund, it could be useful to consider a more dynamic approach that takes account of demographic changes and specific local needs. To this end, it is essential to use constantly updated allocation criteria that ensure greater transparency in the parameters governing the allocation of the performance share.

Reflection along these lines could help to ensure a more balanced and sustainable mobility system at national level.

Want to know more?

For more information and further insight on this topic, write to us and we will get back to you shortly.

Contact Us