Expansion opportunities in the European market for Italian local public transport operators
The Italian local public transport market is currently dotted with foreign operators, such as France's Ratp Dev in Tuscany and Germany's Arriva in Lombardy and Piedmont. In every case, these are large operators that decide to invest in Italy, often by acquiring small local public transport operators…
In this article
- How to define an expansion strategy
- Drivers and development horizons
- Degree of population concentration in European countries
- Presence of international operators in the market
- Regulatory framework and award process for local public transport services
- Who are the international operators in Europe?
- Contract characteristics and barriers to market entry
- Transfer of staff when the operator changes: how does it work?
How to define an expansion strategy
The Italian local public transport market is currently dotted with foreign operators, such as France's Ratp Dev in Tuscany and Germany's Arriva in Lombardy and Piedmont. In every case, these are large operators that decide to invest in Italy, often by acquiring small local public transport operators and taking part in public tenders.
Trenitalia and ATM Milano are the only Italian operators to have entered a foreign market.
By contrast, Italian road-based public transport operators struggle to enter foreign markets because of their small company size, which is a constraint on expansion into other countries.
That said, developing the right strategy, one that takes into account the right drivers and the company's specific characteristics, can be the key to investing successfully in the European market.
Drivers and development horizons
The main drivers that can encourage Italian local public transport operators to invest abroad are the following.
Degree of population concentration in European countries
The figure below provides an overview of the share and distribution of cities within the European Union. Using Eurostat's definition and methodology (based on population size and density), there are 811 cities in the 28 EU Member States with an urban-centre population of at least 50,000 inhabitants.
The chart gives an idea of the importance of urban public transport in these countries in terms of the number of potential passengers.
| S (50k-100k inhabitants) | M (100k-250k) | L (250k-500k) | XL (500k-1,000k) | XXL (1,000k-5,000k) | Global city (>5,000k) | Totale | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EE | 0 | 0 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 |
| SK | 4 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 6 |
| LT | 0 | 3 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 5 |
| LV | 2 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 3 |
| IE | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 4 |
| FI | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 6 |
| CZ | 15 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 19 |
| NL | 20 | 20 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 44 |
| DK | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 3 |
| AT | 0 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 4 |
| HU | 3 | 3 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 7 |
| SE | 10 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 14 |
| BG | 11 | 3 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 16 |
| RO | 12 | 12 | 8 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 33 |
| EL | 2 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 7 |
| PT | 10 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 14 |
| BE | 5 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 10 |
| PL | 37 | 8 | 5 | 5 | 2 | 0 | 57 |
| ES | 43 | 37 | 10 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 96 |
| IT | 43 | 13 | 10 | 2 | 5 | 0 | 73 |
| DE | 61 | 39 | 10 | 6 | 4 | 0 | 120 |
| FR | 60 | 40 | 5 | 3 | 0 | 1 | 109 |
| UK | 42 | 43 | 10 | 4 | 1 | 1 | 101 |
| HR | 0 | 3 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 4 |
Presence of international operators in the market
In several countries, urban public transport is characterised by a high number of internal operators, particularly in large cities, where national operators run entire integrated public transport networks, including buses, trams and metro.
The use of competitive tendering has become more widespread over the last 10 years, enabling the growth of numerous international companies in the urban public transport sector that operate across Europe and beyond.
This is the case with several French companies, such as Keolis, Transdev and RATP Dev.
Keolis and Transdev operate in around 5 or 6 European countries (excluding France). Other major European operators include Arriva DB, Nobina and Abellio (a subsidiary of the Dutch railway company NS).
The following map shows the presence of international operators in the European bus market.
| Paese | Valore |
|---|---|
| Bosnia ed Erzegovina | Between 1% and 20% |
| Belgio | None: 100% domestic operators |
| Bulgaria | Between 1% and 20% |
| Repubblica Ceca | Between 1% and 20% |
| Germania | Between 1% and 20% |
| Danimarca | More than 60% |
| Estonia | None: 100% domestic operators |
| Spagna | Between 1% and 20% |
| Finlandia | Between 20% and 60% |
| Francia | More than 60% |
| Regno Unito | Between 20% and 60% |
| Grecia | None: 100% domestic operators |
| Croazia | Between 1% and 20% |
| Ungheria | Between 1% and 20% |
| Irlanda | None: 100% domestic operators |
| Italia | Between 1% and 20% |
| Lituania | None: 100% domestic operators |
| Lettonia | None: 100% domestic operators |
| Paesi Bassi | More than 60% |
| Norvegia | Between 20% and 60% |
| Polonia | Between 1% and 20% |
| Portogallo | Between 1% and 20% |
| Romania | Between 1% and 20% |
| Svezia | Between 20% and 60% |
| Slovenia | Between 1% and 20% |
| Slovacchia | Between 1% and 20% |
A strong presence of international operators within a country also means high competitiveness. On the other hand, entering a closed local public transport market as a foreign operator could increase the chances of remaining there for much longer.
Regulatory framework and award process for local public transport services
Under Regulation 1370/2007, internal operators that receive a direct award are not permitted to take part in tender procedures outside their own network (Article 5(b)). However, exceptions are possible during the transition period and where the competent authority intends to put out to tender a contract previously awarded directly (Article 5(c)). Organising a competitive tender and putting its own internal operator into competition is a strategic decision for the competent authority.
France, the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, Italy, Sweden and Germany were the first to see international operators grow in their respective markets.
| Paese | Valore | |
|---|---|---|
| Austria | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | Closed markets |
| Bosnia ed Erzegovina | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | |
| Belgio | Tenders cover between 40% and 60% of urban public transport | |
| Bulgaria | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | |
| Repubblica Ceca | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | |
| Germania | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | Closed markets |
| Danimarca | Tenders cover around 80% of urban public transport | High competition |
| Estonia | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | |
| Spagna | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | Closed markets |
| Finlandia | Tenders cover around 80% of urban public transport | |
| Francia | Tenders cover around 80% of urban public transport | High competition |
| Regno Unito | Tenders cover around 80% of urban public transport | High competition |
| Grecia | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | Closed markets |
| Croazia | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | |
| Ungheria | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | |
| Irlanda | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | Closed markets |
| Italia | Tenders cover between 40% and 60% of urban public transport | High competition |
| Lituania | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | |
| Lettonia | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | Closed markets |
| Paesi Bassi | Tenders cover around 80% of urban public transport | High competition |
| Norvegia | Tenders cover around 80% of urban public transport | High competition |
| Polonia | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | Closed markets |
| Portogallo | Tenders cover around 80% of urban public transport | High competition |
| Romania | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | Closed markets |
| Svezia | Tenders cover around 80% of urban public transport | High competition |
| Slovenia | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) | |
| Slovacchia | Mainly direct award. Use of tenders remains marginal (<30%) |
The previous figure gives an indicative overview of the type of procedure used in each country to award lots in the urban public transport sector:
- In Belgium, Greece, Ireland and Luxembourg, all urban bus services are directly awarded to an internal operator.
- In all other countries, both types of award are used (tender and/or direct award).
- In the United Kingdom (England (outside London), Scotland and Wales), direct award is very rare and only possible in very specific cases.
- In Sweden and Finland, direct award is regulated so that it is used only for “exceptions”, and only a few municipally owned companies currently exist.
- In Germany, most cities award contracts directly to an internal operator. There are some examples of tenders for mainly regional bus services and, to a rather limited extent, for small urban networks.
- In Italy, the use of tendering has increased in recent years, but has not reached levels as high as in France or the Netherlands. The use of competitive tendering has increased particularly over the last 10 years in the Netherlands and Finland, where it now covers over 80% of bus lines.
An exceptional situation is found in the United Kingdom, where most urban bus services in England (excluding London), Wales and Scotland are provided on a commercial basis, with bus lines put out to tender only in exceptional cases.
In more than 10 Member States, competitive tendering is used rather marginally, mainly in small and medium-sized urban areas. In the United Kingdom, Sweden, France (excluding Paris), Finland (only in the Helsinki metropolitan area), the Netherlands, Denmark and Norway, tendering had already been implemented before the adoption of Regulation 1370/2007.
There is a tendency to award urban public transport networks (road and rail) directly to an internal operator in capital cities or very large urban areas.
There are exceptions, such as London or Helsinki, where urban rail services are provided in-house or by an internal operator and bus lines are put out to tender. One exception is Stockholm, where all urban public transport (UTP) services are contracted out to different operators (including the metro).
Who are the international operators in Europe?
International companies hold a significant share in only 7 Member States, namely those that have also introduced competitive tendering on a large scale as the main form of award. In most Member States, they play only a limited role in the market.
| Paese | Valore | |
|---|---|---|
| Bosnia ed Erzegovina | Between 1% and 20% | |
| Belgio | None: 100% domestic operators | |
| Bulgaria | Between 1% and 20% | |
| Repubblica Ceca | Between 1% and 20% | |
| Germania | Between 1% and 20% | The first open markets |
| Danimarca | More than 60% | |
| Estonia | None: 100% domestic operators | |
| Spagna | Between 1% and 20% | |
| Finlandia | Between 20% and 60% | |
| Francia | More than 60% | The first open markets |
| Regno Unito | Between 20% and 60% | The first open markets, Other international operators |
| Grecia | None: 100% domestic operators | |
| Croazia | Between 1% and 20% | |
| Ungheria | Between 1% and 20% | |
| Irlanda | None: 100% domestic operators | Non-European operators |
| Italia | Between 1% and 20% | The first open markets |
| Lituania | None: 100% domestic operators | |
| Lettonia | None: 100% domestic operators | |
| Paesi Bassi | More than 60% | The first open markets |
| Norvegia | Between 20% and 60% | |
| Polonia | Between 1% and 20% | |
| Portogallo | Between 1% and 20% | |
| Romania | Between 1% and 20% | |
| Svezia | Between 20% and 60% | Non-European operators |
| Slovenia | Between 1% and 20% | |
| Slovacchia | Between 1% and 20% |
The Italian context differs from that of other European countries with comparable market size, including France, the United Kingdom and Germany, where, despite their different award systems, the market has given rise to large operators, also active beyond national borders, with levels of efficiency and profitability well above the average for Italian operators.
Operator concentration was produced autonomously by the market, and in some cases (particularly in France) encouraged, but not forced, by the public sector.
The main European local public transport groups have adopted a concentrated corporate structure combined with a decentralised organisational structure, which preserves the business continuity and autonomy of the companies progressively acquired by the group.
The decentralised organisation, characterised by a large number of subsidiaries that are autonomous in running the service, appears to enable these groups to:
- adapt to differences in the legislative and regulatory framework in force across and within the various national and local markets;
- relate optimally to the local area, the public authority and their users;
- deliver the service with a lean organisation that is more responsive to local market signals;
- make local management accountable for objectives.
Contract characteristics and barriers to market entry
In general, most contracts covering local public transport services (except in France, Belgium and Ireland, where the organising authorities largely own the rolling stock, both buses and light rail) also include the provision of vehicles and maintenance, depending on local or regional needs. The quality and technical specifications of the buses play an important role in the award of the contract. The maintenance and provision of depots (particularly in countries with a high share of tendering) are also of strategic importance. In some cases, operators lease vehicles, rent bus depots or outsource maintenance. Asset maintenance is capital-intensive.
Rolling stock and infrastructure maintenance are barriers to entry because of the high investment required. On the other hand, the contract duration offers the prospect of a return.
| Country | Length of contract | Rolling stock | Maintenance | Infrastructure maintenance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Austria | 8-15 years | |||
| Belgium | 5 years | |||
| Bulgaria | 10 years | |||
| Czech Republic | 8-10 years | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. |
| Germany | 10 years for bus services; up to 22.5 years for mixed services (bus & rail) | |||
| Finland | 5-7 years (with an option to prolong 3 years) | |||
| France | Outside Paris: 5-10 years | |||
| Ireland | 5 years | |||
| Italy | 8-10 years | |||
| Netherlands | 6-10 years | |||
| Sweden | 8 years (option to prolong 3 years) | |||
| UK | London only 5 years (option to prolong 2 years) |
Transfer of staff when the operator changes: how does it work?
In France, Finland, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom, staff are transferred on the basis of national legislation or the sector's collective agreement when the operator changes following a tender.
In Austria, Denmark, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Slovenia, Sweden and Bulgaria, there would generally be no transfer of staff, since in most cases a change of operator cannot be considered a transfer of undertaking under the national legislation implementing EU Directive 2001/23/EC on transfers of undertakings, and there are no other national rules for this situation.
| Country | Rules on staff transfer |
|---|---|
| Germany | No transfer of staff when the operator changes, under national legislation for urban public transport; not considered a transfer of undertaking (although this depends on whether assets are transferred). |
| Denmark | Transfer of staff when the operator changes may occur if it is considered a transfer of undertaking under national law (transfer of business), which was found to happen often; all staff linked to the service will be transferred and must be listed in the tender documents. |
| Finland | Transfer of staff when the operator changes does not occur by law, as it is not considered a transfer of undertaking under national law; instead, staff are transferred in every change of operator under an agreement between the social partners that is binding on all operators, covering the staff directly affected. |
| France | Transfer of staff when the operator changes is considered a transfer of undertaking under national legislation – Labour Code: Article L1224-1 of the Labour Code applies if the contracted service is performed by a single autonomous entity; the staff to be transferred will be listed by the authority in the tender documents. |
| Hungary | No transfer of staff when the operator changes; not considered a transfer of undertaking under national law (although this may depend on whether assets are transferred). |
| Ireland | No transfer of staff when the operator changes; not considered a transfer of undertaking under national law (although this may depend on whether assets are transferred). |
| Netherlands | Transport Law obliges transfer of staff in case of change of operator; concerns mainly staff directly affected and a percentage of indirectly affected staff. |
| Slovenia | No transfer of staff when the operator changes; not considered a transfer of undertaking under national law (although this may depend on whether assets are transferred). |
| Sweden | No transfer of staff when the operator changes; not considered a transfer of undertaking under national law (although this may depend on whether assets are transferred). |
| UK | A change of operator is considered a transfer of undertaking under the 2006 national legislation on the Transfer of Undertakings and Service Provision Changes; it requires the transfer of the staff concerned (identified with the service). |
In conclusion, the ideal strategy for entering a foreign market is essentially based on the right mix of:
- The concentration of international operators in the countries analysed;
- The percentage of competitive tenders in the country;
- The number of inhabitants in urban areas;
- The contract characteristics and barriers to entry.
Want to know more?
For more information and further insight on this topic, write to us and we will get back to you shortly.
