The sustainability of local public transport service contracts in the current context
In Italy, before Covid, the local and regional public transport sector employed over 124,000 people. With around 49,000 vehicles, it covered over 1.8 billion vehicle-km and 228.6 million train-km a year, carrying…
In this article
- Between public service obligation orders, new tenders and requests to extend contracts under Decree-Law No. 4/2022
- The economic balance of service contracts
- Fare revenue forecasts 2022–2023
- The impact of rising traction costs
- The impact of the CCNL renewal: pay increases
- The impact of investment and rising interest rates
- The impact of inflation on operating costs
- The difficult economic balance of employment contracts
- The current situation of local public transport service awards
- Local public transport service award acts in Italy
- Methods of awarding the service
- How to draw up the forecast economic and financial plan (PEF)
Between public service obligation orders, new tenders and requests to extend contracts under Decree-Law No. 4/2022
In Italy, before Covid, the local and regional public transport sector employed over 124,000 people. With around 49,000 vehicles, it covered over 1.8 billion vehicle-km and 228.6 million train-km a year, carrying more than 5.5 billion passengers. Overall, the sector generated a turnover of around €12 billion.
| Valore | |
|---|---|
| Lazio | 277 million |
| Lombardy | 276 million |
| Veneto | 142 million |
| Tuscany | 135 million |
| Piedmont | 134 million |
| Emilia-Romagna | 130 million |
| Campania | 123 million |
| Apulia | 119 million |
| Sicily | 92 million |
| Liguria | 64 million |
| Calabria | 62 million |
| Trentino | 62 million |
| Abruzzo | 59 million |
| Friuli-Venezia Giulia | 45 million |
| Marche | 45 million |
| Basilicata | 40 million |
| Sardinia | 33 million |
| Umbria | 33 million |
| Molise | 17 million |
| Valle d'Aosta | 7 million |
| Regione | Valore |
|---|---|
| Abruzzo | 59 million km |
| Basilicata | 40 million km |
| Calabria | 62 million km |
| Campania | 123 million km |
| Emilia-Romagna | 130 million km |
| Friuli-Venezia Giulia | 45 million km |
| Lazio | 277 million km |
| Liguria | 64 million km |
| Lombardia | 276 million km |
| Marche | 45 million km |
| Molise | 17 million km |
| Piemonte | 134 million km |
| Puglia | 119 million km |
| Sardegna | 33 million km |
| Sicilia | 92 million km |
| Toscana | 135 million km |
| Trentino-Alto Adige | 62 million km |
| Umbria | 33 million km |
| Valle d'Aosta | 7 million km |
| Veneto | 142 million km |
| Valore | |
|---|---|
| Lombardy | 1,396 € million |
| Lazio | 1,010 € million |
| Tuscany | 460 € million |
| Sicily | 411 € million |
| Apulia | 369 € million |
| Piedmont | 271 € million |
| Emilia-Romagna | 269 € million |
| Veneto | 253 € million |
| Campania | 244 € million |
| Liguria | 220 € million |
| Sardinia | 203 € million |
| Friuli-Venezia Giulia | 155 € million |
| Abruzzo | 149 € million |
| Calabria | 131 € million |
| Marche | 108 € million |
| Basilicata | 105 € million |
| Umbria | 101 € million |
| Aut. Prov. Trento | 94 € million |
| Aut. Prov. Bolzano | 69 € million |
| Molise | 42 € million |
| Valle d'Aosta | 31 € million |
The economic balance of service contracts
The impact of lost fare revenue
With the spread of the pandemic, local public transport and mobility were completely upended.
During the lockdown, passenger numbers collapsed by more than -90% compared with pre-pandemic levels, which translated into an average national loss of -50% including the pre-Covid months of January and February, and -68% excluding the pre-pandemic months of 2020.
In 2021 too, the impact of Covid-19 and of the containment measures adopted by the Government (e.g. reductions in the maximum capacity of vehicles) led to a significant reduction in demand for mobility ( the reduction in passengers in 2021 compared with 2019 averaged -42%).
| Valore | |
|---|---|
| Lombardy | 924 € million |
| Lazio | 494 € million |
| Veneto | 395 € million |
| Tuscany | 312 € million |
| Emilia-Romagna | 269 € million |
| Piedmont | 259 € million |
| Campania | 214 € million |
| Liguria | 163 € million |
| Sicily | 161 € million |
| Apulia | 105 € million |
| Friuli-Venezia Giulia | 66 € million |
| Marche | 60 € million |
| Sardinia | 57 € million |
| Abruzzo | 49 € million |
| Calabria | 47 € million |
| Umbria | 42 € million |
| Aut. Prov. Trento | 22 € million |
| Basilicata | 16 € million |
| Molise | 9 € million |
| Valle d'Aosta | 6 € million |
| Aut. Prov. Bolzano | 2 € million |
Before Covid, Lombardy was the region with the highest fare revenue, at around €924 million, followed by Lazio and Veneto.
| Valore | |
|---|---|
| Jan 2020 | 0% |
| Feb 2020 | 0% |
| Mar 2020 | -74% |
| Apr 2020 | -90% |
| May 2020 | -78% |
| Jun 2020 | -65% |
| Jul 2020 | -65% |
| Aug 2020 | -30% |
| Sep 2020 | -30% |
| Oct 2020 | -30% |
| Nov 2020 | -30% |
| Dec 2020 | -30% |
The loss of revenue in the year of the pandemic was considerable, reaching -90% in April 2020.
The outlook for the future is not rosy.
Fare revenue forecasts 2022–2023
A survey carried out by the ASSTRA Research Department also made it possible to estimate the effects of Covid-19 on local public transport demand for 2022 and 2023.
| Valore | |
|---|---|
| 2020 | -50% |
| 2021 | -42% |
| 2022 (estimate) | -21% |
| 2023 (estimate) | -12% |
The survey showed demand still below pre-Covid levels, with an estimated decrease compared with 2019 of -21% for 2022 and -12% for 2023.
The impact of rising traction costs
On top of the heavy and serious effects of Covid comes the exponential increase in traction energy costs, which is significantly affecting the economic and financial balance of the local public transport sector.
| Valore | |
|---|---|
| Dec-20 | 0.97 |
| Jan | 1 |
| Feb | 1.05 |
| Mar | 1.07 |
| Apr | 1.07 |
| May | 1.09 |
| Jun | 1.11 |
| Jul | 1.13 |
| Aug | 1.1 |
| Sep | 1.15 |
| Oct | 1.15 |
| Nov | 1.22 |
| Dec-21 | 1.19 |
| Jan-22 | 1.27 |
| Feb | 1.37 |
| Mar | 1.54 |
| Apr | 1.42 |
| May | 1.4 |
| Jun | 1.55 |
| Jul | 1.42 |
| Aug | 1.36 |
| Sep | 1.33 |
| Oct-22 | 1.44 |
| Valore | |
|---|---|
| Dec-20 | 0.57 |
| Jan-21 | 0.55 |
| Feb | 0.56 |
| Mar | 0.55 |
| Apr | 0.56 |
| May | 0.55 |
| Jun | 0.56 |
| Jul | 0.56 |
| Aug | 0.58 |
| Sep | 0.63 |
| Oct | 0.92 |
| Nov | 0.99 |
| Dec | 1.02 |
| Jan-22 | 1.07 |
| Feb | 1.07 |
| Mar | 1.19 |
| Apr | 1.28 |
| May | 1.24 |
| Jun | 1.19 |
| Jul | 1.51 |
| Aug | 1.74 |
| Sep-22 | 2.09 |
| Valore | |
|---|---|
| Oct-21 | 0.26 |
| Nov-21 | 0.27 |
| Dec-21 | 0.33 |
| Jan-22 | 0.27 |
| Feb-22 | 0.26 |
| Mar-22 | 0.36 |
| Apr-22 | 0.29 |
| May-22 | 0.26 |
| Jun-22 | 0.31 |
| Jul-22 | 0.5 |
| Aug-22 | 0.59 |
| Sep-22 | 0.48 |
The impact of the CCNL renewal: pay increases
On 10 May 2022, the new agreement renewing the CCNL autoferrotranvieri (the national collective labour agreement for bus, tram and rail workers) was signed. For pay grade 175, the renewal provides for a one-off gross payment of €500 covering the period from 1 January 2021 to 30 June 2022. In addition, for the same pay grade, the renewal provides for a gross increase of €90.00, paid in three instalments.
As a result of this increase, only the following national pay elements will be revalued: overtime, public-holiday and night work; reduced daily allowance; and TFR (severance pay).
From 1 July 2022, a “holiday pay” allowance of €8 gross is introduced, to be paid for each day of leave taken by the employee.
From 1 January 2023, the annual employer contribution to fund the Fondo TPL Salute (the sector's health fund) will be €144 for each employee on a permanent contract.
The impact of investment and rising interest rates
It should be noted that the growth trend in investment continued in both 2021 and 2022: companies further accelerated their spending in 2021, which rose by 21.6% compared with 2020. In 2022, investment spending is expected to accelerate further and could reach +27% compared with the previous year.
| Depreciation | Investment | |
|---|---|---|
| 2020-2021 | 6.2% | 21.6% |
| 2021-2022 | 8.7% | 27.5% |
Total capital investment funding for the local public transport sector amounts to over €32.4 billion (national resources, PNRR (National Recovery and Resilience Plan), FNC (National Complementary Fund) and other funding sources up to 2033).
Around 12,700 new registrations are expected in the period 2021-2027.
To finance their ambitious investment plans and avoid losing the grants made available, transport companies have often resorted to multi-year bank loans. The current context of sharply rising interest rates therefore puts further pressure on financial costs.
The impact of inflation on operating costs
The exponential increase in the programmed inflation rate set by the MEF (Ministry of Economy and Finance) for 2022 and next year (2023) will weigh heavily on the operating costs of local public transport companies, putting further pressure on their financial statements.
| Valore | |
|---|---|
| 2020 | -0.2% |
| 2021 | 0.5% |
| 2022 | 7.1% |
| 2023 | 4.9% |
The difficult economic balance of employment contracts
Public transport companies continue to find it difficult to pass price increases on downstream, unlike what is happening in other sectors: the pass-through is in fact severely limited by the absence of a regulatory system providing for automatic cost-adjustment mechanisms (as is the case for other public services), and the ability to act on fares is discretionary, which inevitably implies an erosion of the sector's margins and profitability. The combination of critical issues that companies are facing in 2022 is causing an inevitable and very serious erosion of companies' margins and profitability, with a major impact on their economic and financial balance.
Assumption based on a medium-sized company
Government intervention made it possible to fully cover the losses recorded in 2020 and partially cover those in 2021, thanks to the compensation paid and the guarantee that service contract payments would be paid in full, without deductions or penalties for the reduction in vehicle-kilometres operated.
Compensation did not always arrive in proportion to the losses: there is a sense that the less efficient companies benefited more, to the detriment of the more efficient ones.
The current situation of local public transport service awards
In Italy, around 87% of award acts are currently extensions of expired or expiring contracts.
In some regions (very few), tender procedures are under way, while in others the documents are being prepared to launch tenders in the coming months.
In a great many cases, transport companies are requesting extensions of their bus service contracts under Article 24(5-bis) of Decree-Law No. 4/2022 by drawing up the PEF (economic and financial plan).
Local public transport service award acts in Italy
Pre-Covid data (before 2019) show around 1,600 valid award acts concluded between 650 contracting authorities and 775 economic operators.
| Valore | |
|---|---|
| Lazio | 305 |
| Sicily | 215 |
| Campania | 156 |
| Lombardy | 107 |
| Apulia | 87 |
| Veneto | 87 |
| Tuscany | 85 |
| Abruzzo | 79 |
| Piedmont | 76 |
| Sardinia | 65 |
| Basilicata | 64 |
| Marche | 53 |
| Liguria | 38 |
| Molise | 32 |
| Calabria | 32 |
| Aut. Prov. Bolzano | 29 |
| Emilia-Romagna | 28 |
| Umbria | 19 |
| Friuli-Venezia Giulia | 15 |
| Aut. Prov. Trento | 11 |
| Valle d'Aosta | 4 |
Methods of awarding the service
Across the various transport modes (bus, metro, tram and other), 72.50% of the service was awarded by direct award, 22.16% by tender and 5.34% through in-house procedures.
| Quota | |
|---|---|
| Direct award | 72.5% |
| Tender | 22.16% |
| In-house | 5.34% |
How to draw up the forecast economic and financial plan (PEF)
D.L. n. 4/2022 (Decree-Law No 4/2022) provides that «In order to support operators in the local and regional public transport sector and to mitigate the negative effects of the prevention and containment measures adopted for the Covid-19 epidemiological emergency, as well as to support investment, the competent authorities may [apply] Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007, where the operator of local and regional public transport services undertakes to make significant investments, self-financed at least in part and based on an economic and financial plan that complies with the regulatory provisions and measures in force, with a depreciation period extending beyond the expiry of the award. … In this case, an extension is deemed necessary, which may in no case go beyond 31 December 2026».
Drawing up the forecast PEF, whether for awards by tender or for requests to extend contracts under Decree-Law No. 4/2022, is, in the current context of uncertainty, more difficult and complicated than ever.
An incorrectly structured PEF, together with the resulting contractual commitments between the awarded company and the contracting authority, could permanently compromise the economic and financial sustainability of the service contract.
Want to know more?
For more information and further insight on this topic, write to us and we will get back to you shortly.
