---
title: "Employment dynamics in the local public transport sector: structural problems and potential solutions | Basco&T"
description: "The shortage of bus drivers is becoming an increasingly worrying problem in many Italian cities and regions. It can be attributed to a number of factors, first and foremost pay, which, despite the renewals of the…"
canonical_url: "https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/il-ruolo-dei-sindacati-nellattuale-carenza-di-autisti-nel-trasporto-pubblico"
locale: en
meta:
  "og:description": "The shortage of bus drivers is becoming an increasingly worrying problem in many Italian cities and regions. It can be attributed to a number of factors, first and foremost pay, which, despite the renewals of the…"
  "og:image": "https://www.basco-t.com/api/assets/884418d2-86af-421a-8d82-c8654a2bc5f4?width=1200&height=630&fit=cover&format=jpg&quality=80"
  "og:image:alt": "Hands of a driver in a suit and tie on a bus steering wheel, with the title of the study on the bus driver shortage and the role of trade unions"
  "og:title": "Employment dynamics in the local public transport sector: structural problems and potential solutions | Basco&T"
  "twitter:description": "The shortage of bus drivers is becoming an increasingly worrying problem in many Italian cities and regions. It can be attributed to a number of factors, first and foremost pay, which, despite the renewals of the…"
  "twitter:image:alt": "Hands of a driver in a suit and tie on a bus steering wheel, with the title of the study on the bus driver shortage and the role of trade unions"
  "twitter:title": "Employment dynamics in the local public transport sector: structural problems and potential solutions | Basco&T"
---

> Index of every page on this site: [llms.txt](https://www.basco-t.com/llms.txt)

[←** All insights**](https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights)**10 May 2023**

# **Employment dynamics in the local public transport sector:****structural problems and potential solutions**

The shortage of bus drivers is becoming an increasingly worrying problem in many Italian cities and regions. It can be attributed to a number of factors, first and foremost pay, which, despite the renewals of the…

![Hands of a driver in a suit and tie on a bus steering wheel, with the title of the study on the bus driver shortage and the role of trade unions](https://www.basco-t.com/api/assets/884418d2-86af-421a-8d82-c8654a2bc5f4)

## The role of trade unions in the current driver shortage: reduced working performance at the expense of pay

The shortage of bus drivers is becoming an increasingly worrying problem in many Italian cities and regions. It can be attributed to a number of factors, first and foremost pay, which, despite the renewals of the national collective agreement for the bus, tram and rail sector (Contratto Nazionale Autoferrotranvieri) in recent years, does not help make the job attractive. Indeed, drivers' purchasing power has been eroding, partly as a result of the exponential rise in the cost of living.

**So the solution would seem simple: raise salaries**. But at present this solution is not feasible for most local public transport companies. Labour costs account for between 55% and 70% of total costs, and an across-the-board (*tout court*) wage increase without a corresponding increase in productivity would seriously jeopardise the companies' financial sustainability and, ultimately, the sustainability of the service itself.

It is therefore necessary to analyse in detail the structural causes that have led to this situation, in order to try to find feasible and economically sustainable solutions for local public transport companies.

To frame the problem, it should be said in general that over recent years negotiations between trade unions and local public transport companies have, in most cases, failed to make the management of driving staff genuinely more efficient, **ending up having a negative impact on working performance without producing substantial economic benefits for drivers.**

## The figures

According to an ANAV estimate, approximately 15,000 new drivers will be needed over the next three years.

The average age is also rising. **According to the Ministry of Transport, in Italy 45.8% of drivers holding a CQC (** Carta di Qualificazione del Conducente, the Driver Certificate of Professional Competence required to carry goods or passengers by road) **are over 50, compared with 18.1% who are under 40. Only 0.4% are under 24.**

And yet, despite peaks in unemployment in the years following the 2008 economic crisis, the unemployment rate has not changed significantly over the last 20 years.

**Unemployment rate by geographical area**

Population aged 15 to 64, 2004-2022

SouthCentreNorth

Unemployment rate by geographical area

| Anno | South | Centre | North |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 2004 | 15.1% | 6.6% | 4.4% |
| 2005 | 14.5% | 6.6% | 4.3% |
| 2006 | 12.4% | 6.2% | 3.9% |
| 2007 | 11.2% | 5.4% | 3.6% |
| 2008 | 12.2% | 6.2% | 4% |
| 2009 | 12.8% | 7.4% | 5.4% |
| 2010 | 13.7% | 7.8% | 6.1% |
| 2011 | 13.9% | 7.8% | 6% |
| 2012 | 17.6% | 9.8% | 7.6% |
| 2013 | 20.2% | 11% | 8.6% |
| 2014 | 21.2% | 11.7% | 8.9% |
| 2015 | 19.8% | 10.9% | 8.2% |
| 2016 | 20% | 10.7% | 7.7% |
| 2017 | 19.7% | 10.2% | 7% |
| 2018 | 18.8% | 9.6% | 6.7% |
| 2019 | 17.9% | 8.9% | 6.2% |
| 2020 | 16.5% | 8.4% | 6.1% |
| 2021 | 16.6% | 8.8% | 6.1% |
| 2022 | 14.6% | 7.1% | 5.1% |

*Data source: ISTAT Data analysis by Basco&T Consulting®*

> In the past, southern Italy (the Mezzogiorno) was a large pool of drivers on which companies in northern Italy in particular drew.

**In 2022, the unemployment rate among upper-secondary school graduates in Italy stood at 7.9%**, based on the unemployed population aged 15 to 64.

**Unemployment rate by educational attainment**

Population aged over 15, 2021-2022 (%)

20212022

**Upper-secondary diploma**

9.3%

7.9%

**No qualification, primary or lower-secondary certificate**

13.7%

11.9%

Unemployment rate by educational attainment

|  | 2021 | 2022 |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Upper-secondary diploma | 9.3% | 7.9% |
| No qualification, primary or lower-secondary certificate | 13.7% | 11.9% |

## Drivers' loss of purchasing power

Under the National Collective Labour Agreement (July 2022), pay for a public transport operative working as a driver (pay grade 140) is **€1,485 gross per month (approximately €1,150 net). The increases at each renewal since 2009 have been approximately €24–28 gross (pay grade 140).**

**Renewals of the public transport workers’ national collective agreement (CCNL)**

Gross salary trend, pay grade 140

Gross salaryIncrease at each renewal

1 May 2009 to 31 October 20151 November 2015 to 30 June 20161 July 2016 to 30 September 2017October 2017 to 30 June 20221 July 2022 to date

Renewals of the public transport workers’ national collective agreement (CCNL)

|  | Gross salary | Increase at each renewal |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1 May 2009 to 31 October 2015 | 1,381 € | – |
| 1 November 2015 to 30 June 2016 | 1,409 € | 28 € |
| 1 July 2016 to 30 September 2017 | 1,437 € | 28 € |
| October 2017 to 30 June 2022 | 1,461 € | 24 € |
| 1 July 2022 to date | 1,485 € | 24 € |

*Data analysis by Basco&T Consulting®*

Despite the increases from the renewals of the national collective agreement for the bus, tram and rail sector, bus drivers' purchasing power has gradually eroded due to rising inflation.

**Average annual inflation rate**

2009-2023 (2023 estimated)

Average annual inflation rate

| Anno | Inflation |
| --- | --- |
| 2009 | 0.8% |
| 2010 | 1.5% |
| 2011 | 2.7% |
| 2012 | 3% |
| 2013 | 1.2% |
| 2014 | 0.2% |
| 2015 | 0.1% |
| 2016 | -0.1% |
| 2017 | 1.2% |
| 2018 | 1.2% |
| 2019 | 0.6% |
| 2020 | -0.2% |
| 2021 | 1.9% |
| 2022 | 8.1% |
| 2023 | 9% |

*Data source: ISTAT Data analysis by Basco&T Consulting®*

In fact, **since 2018 cumulative inflation has exceeded the cumulative wage increases provided for by contract renewals.** This gap widened sharply from 2022 onwards with the exponential rise in the cost of living.

**Cumulative gross salary increase vs. cumulative inflation rate**

Gross salary at pay grade 140, 2016-2023 (%)

Cumulative gross salary increase, pay grade 140Cumulative inflation rate

Cumulative gross salary increase vs. cumulative inflation rate

| Anno | Cumulative gross salary increase, pay grade 140 | Cumulative inflation rate |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 2016 | 2% | 0% |
| 2017 | 4% | 1.2% |
| 2022 | 6% | 12.8% |
| 2023 | 8% | 21.8% |

*Data analysis by Basco&T Consulting®*

## Net pay is also weighed down by the tax wedge

The OECD has published its ‘Taxing Wages 2022’ report (covering 2021) on the tax wedge, which highlights the differences among the 36 countries that are members of the Organisation.

**Tax wedge on labour costs**

OECD countries (%)

Australia

27.1%USA

28.4%United Kingdom

31.3%Canada

31.5%Ireland

34%Netherlands

34.9%Poland

35.3%Denmark

35.4%Norway

36%Greece

36.7%Lithuania

37.6%Estonia

38.1%Spain

39.3%Turkey

39.9%Czech Republic

39.9%Luxembourg

40.2%Latvia

40.5%Slovakia

41.3%Portugal

41.8%Sweden

42.6%Finland

42.7%Hungary

43.2%Slovenia

43.6%**Italy**

**46.5%**France

47%Austria

47.8%Germany

48.1%Belgium

52.6%

Tax wedge on labour costs

|  | Valore |
| --- | --- |
| Australia | 27.1% |
| USA | 28.4% |
| United Kingdom | 31.3% |
| Canada | 31.5% |
| Ireland | 34% |
| Netherlands | 34.9% |
| Poland | 35.3% |
| Denmark | 35.4% |
| Norway | 36% |
| Greece | 36.7% |
| Lithuania | 37.6% |
| Estonia | 38.1% |
| Spain | 39.3% |
| Turkey | 39.9% |
| Czech Republic | 39.9% |
| Luxembourg | 40.2% |
| Latvia | 40.5% |
| Slovakia | 41.3% |
| Portugal | 41.8% |
| Sweden | 42.6% |
| Finland | 42.7% |
| Hungary | 43.2% |
| Slovenia | 43.6% |
| Italy | 46.5% |
| France | 47% |
| Austria | 47.8% |
| Germany | 48.1% |
| Belgium | 52.6% |

*Data source: OECD 2022*

**Italy ranks among the top 5**: this means that a standard worker (single and with no dependent children) is subject to a tax wedge of **46.5%.**

**Breakdown of the tax wedge in Italy**

2021

**46.5%**total tax wedge

**15.3%****7.2%****24%**

Personal income tax**15.3%**Employee social security contributions**7.2%**Employer social security contributions**24%**

Breakdown of the tax wedge in Italy

|  | Quota |
| --- | --- |
| Personal income tax | 15.3% |
| Employee social security contributions | 7.2% |
| Employer social security contributions | 24% |

*Data source: OECD 2022*

It should be stressed that the **cut in the tax wedge, planned from May 2023**, **of around 6% to 7%,** depending on the worker's income, should help increase bus drivers' purchasing power.

The tax wedge cut had been announced with the approval of the DEF 2023 (Economic and Financial Document) and was then confirmed by the Decreto Lavoro (Labour Decree) approved on 1 May.

## Second-level agreements and reduced working performance

Over recent years, negotiations between trade unions and local public transport companies have focused mainly on **company-level, second-level regulatory aspects which, in most cases,** have not made the management of driving staff genuinely more efficient, **ending up having a negative impact on working performance without producing substantial economic benefits for drivers.**

> In particular, second-level company agreements have made shift planning more «rigid» for local public transport companies, resulting in higher labour costs for the same level of performance.

## Actual driving hours

Indeed, if we look at the **working hours of driving staff**, which the national collective agreement for the bus, tram and rail sector sets at **6 hours 40 minutes a day** or 40 hours a week, supplementary agreements, which tend to «straitjacket» planning, mean that **actual driving hours are in some cases reduced by 30%-40%, bringing actual performance down to 3.5-4.5 hours (drivers' actual driving hours).**

In some «paradoxical» cases, daily planning is unable to fill the working time of driving staff on some shifts, while on others overtime is needed to make up the shortfall.

Things become even more complicated for local public transport companies formed by merging several companies. Negotiations between the company and the trade unions have almost never achieved genuine harmonisation of second-level rules, effectively making the management of driving staff inefficient.

> Note: it should be stressed that the figures reported refer to average values and that there is a natural variation between companies, particularly between publicly owned and privately owned companies.

## Average attendance days of driving staff

Analysing the **average attendance days of driving staff**, an important indicator for assessing the efficiency of staff management, leads to the same conclusion. The national collective agreement for the bus, tram and rail sector provides for **approximately 270 workable days** for driving staff, i.e. the total number of days per year on which driving staff are available for service. In reality, **drivers' actual average attendance** at some companies is around **210-230 days actually worked** (pre-COVID figures).

Here too, it must be said that negotiations between the company and the trade unions have, in most cases, not focused on achieving a concrete increase in the productivity of driving staff, and have failed to find a useful tool for achieving these objectives even in the **performance bonus (Premio di Risultato)**.

Of course, there are also some highly virtuous companies in the local public transport landscape.

> The current finances of local public transport companies cannot sustain wage increases for drivers without a corresponding increase in the efficiency of their working performance.

> Note: labour costs account for between 55% and 70% of the total costs of local public transport companies. Of this cost, 70-80% relates to driving staff.

Local public transport companies have launched many initiatives to attract new drivers, for example:

• setting up *Academies* for recruiting and providing ongoing training to driving staff,

• paying the costs of obtaining the CQC,

• and even new corporate welfare tools such as company gyms.

**But the main issue remains pay. Drivers' pay must be made attractive and decent in economic terms**.

> Note: according to a recent ISFORT survey of a sample of companies, 79% of respondents believe that raising pay is the right recipe for revitalising the bus driver profession.

It is therefore necessary to rethink the premises of negotiations between the company and the trade unions so that they focus more on workers' real needs (i.e. higher wages), without, however, losing sight of the need for local public transport companies to keep their accounts balanced.

> In other words, negotiations need to focus on optimising working performance in conjunction with improving drivers' pay, encouraging teamwork and allowing part of the economic returns generated by efficiency gains to be distributed to workers. In this way, drivers' interest in higher wages could be pursued without having a negative impact on the finances of local public transport companies.

## **Want to know more?**

For more information and further insight on this topic, write to us and we will get back to you shortly.

[**Contact Us **](https://www.basco-t.com/en/contatti)

```json
{"@context":"https://schema.org","@graph":[{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en#website","@type":"WebSite","inLanguage":"en-GB","name":"Basco&T","url":"https://www.basco-t.com/en","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#identity"},"translationOfWork":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/it#website"}},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/il-ruolo-dei-sindacati-nellattuale-carenza-di-autisti-nel-trasporto-pubblico#webpage","@type":"WebPage","datePublished":"2023-05-10","description":"The shortage of bus drivers is becoming an increasingly worrying problem in many Italian cities and regions. It can be attributed to a number of factors, first and foremost pay, which, despite the renewals of the…","name":"Employment dynamics in the local public transport sector: structural problems and potential solutions | Basco&T","url":"https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/il-ruolo-dei-sindacati-nellattuale-carenza-di-autisti-nel-trasporto-pubblico","isPartOf":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en#website"},"potentialAction":[{"@type":"ReadAction","target":["https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/il-ruolo-dei-sindacati-nellattuale-carenza-di-autisti-nel-trasporto-pubblico"]}],"primaryImageOfPage":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#logo"}},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#identity","@type":"Organization","name":"Basco&T","url":"https://www.basco-t.com","logo":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#logo"},"sameAs":["https://www.linkedin.com/company/basco-t/","https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61573738169898","https://www.instagram.com/mobility_metrics/"]},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/il-ruolo-dei-sindacati-nellattuale-carenza-di-autisti-nel-trasporto-pubblico#article","@type":"Article","datePublished":"2023-05-10","description":"The shortage of bus drivers is becoming an increasingly worrying problem in many Italian cities and regions. It can be attributed to a number of factors, first and foremost pay, which, despite the renewals of the…","headline":"Employment dynamics in the local public transport sector: structural problems and potential solutions","inLanguage":"en-GB","thumbnailUrl":"https://www.basco-t.com/api/assets/884418d2-86af-421a-8d82-c8654a2bc5f4","author":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#/schema/person/1"},"image":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#/schema/image/1"},"isPartOf":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/il-ruolo-dei-sindacati-nellattuale-carenza-di-autisti-nel-trasporto-pubblico#webpage"},"mainEntityOfPage":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/en/insights/il-ruolo-dei-sindacati-nellattuale-carenza-di-autisti-nel-trasporto-pubblico#webpage"},"publisher":{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#identity"}},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#/schema/person/1","@type":"Person","name":"Edoardo Tartaglia","url":"https://www.linkedin.com/in/edoardo-tartaglia/"},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#logo","@type":"ImageObject","caption":"Basco&T","contentUrl":"https://www.basco-t.com/logos/Logo Sfondo Bianco.png","inLanguage":"en-GB","url":"https://www.basco-t.com/logos/Logo Sfondo Bianco.png"},{"@id":"https://www.basco-t.com/#/schema/image/1","@type":"ImageObject","contentUrl":"https://www.basco-t.com/api/assets/884418d2-86af-421a-8d82-c8654a2bc5f4","inLanguage":"en-GB","url":"https://www.basco-t.com/api/assets/884418d2-86af-421a-8d82-c8654a2bc5f4"}]}
```

## Sitemap

See the full [sitemap](https://www.basco-t.com/sitemap.md) for all pages.
